Icy Sidewalk and Parking-Lot Falls in Michigan

Michigan winters are brutal on knees, hips, wrists, and backs. One patch of black ice in a store lot and you're on the ground with a fracture that keeps you off work for months. So who pays for it — you, or the property that let the ice build up?

Snow-and-ice falls are some of the most common — and most fiercely defended — injury claims in our state. Property owners and their insurers love to argue that ice in a Michigan winter is just something you should have expected and avoided. The good news is that the law changed in recent years, and these cases are far more winnable than they used to be. Here's how it works and how to protect yourself.

Where These Falls Happen

We see icy-fall injuries all over metro Detroit and across the state, most often at:

• Grocery and retail parking lots where plowing left ridges that melt and refreeze
• Store entrances and vestibules where tracked-in slush turns to ice
• Sidewalks in front of businesses, apartments, and offices
• Gas stations, restaurants, and bank lots
• Apartment-complex walkways, stairs, and lots the landlord is responsible for
• Downspouts and roof runoff that drain across a walkway and refreeze overnight

Common Winter-Fall Injuries

A fall on ice can be far more serious than people assume: broken wrists and arms from bracing the fall, hip fractures (especially dangerous for older adults), torn knee ligaments, tailbone and spine injuries, and concussions or traumatic brain injuries when the head strikes the pavement. Many of these require surgery and long rehabilitation.

Does the Property Owner Owe You Anything?

Yes — a business or landlord that invites the public onto its property has a duty to take reasonable steps to keep it safe, and that includes reasonable snow and ice removal. The question in nearly every case is whether the owner acted reasonably: Did they plow and salt? Did they know a downspout was flooding a walkway? Did they let a known refreeze area go untreated for hours?

The Old "Open and Obvious" Trap — and What Changed

For years, Michigan owners escaped these cases using the open-and-obvious doctrine: if a reasonable person could have seen the ice, the owner owed no duty at all, and the case was dismissed. That made winter falls nearly impossible to win.

In 2023, the Michigan Supreme Court overhauled this rule in Kandil-Elsayed v. F & E Oil. Now, whether a hazard was open and obvious is no longer an automatic defense. The owner still has a duty to use reasonable care, and the obviousness of the ice is weighed as part of comparative fault — how careful you were versus how careful the owner was. That is a major shift in favor of injured people, and it means many falls that would have been thrown out a few years ago now have real value.

Michigan Comparative Fault: Why Your Care Still Matters

Michigan uses modified comparative negligence. If you're found partly at fault — wearing smooth-soled shoes, looking at your phone, taking a shortcut across an unplowed area — your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault. If you're more than 50% at fault, you can't recover non-economic damages like pain and suffering at all. This is exactly why documenting the owner's failures (untreated ice, no salt, hours since the last plow) is so important: it shifts the fault balance back toward the property.

Landlords and Apartment Complexes

If you rent, your landlord generally has both a common-law and a statutory duty to keep common areas — lots, sidewalks, and stairwells — reasonably safe and fit for use. Icy common areas at an apartment complex are a frequent source of valid claims, and the lease usually can't waive the landlord's core duties. Report the hazard in writing so there's a record the landlord knew.

Government Sidewalks: Shorter Deadlines

If you fell on a public sidewalk maintained by a city or county, different rules apply. Claims against government entities carry special notice requirements and much shorter deadlines — often you must give written notice within 120 days, and specific defect standards apply. Miss that window and the claim can be lost no matter how strong it is. Don't assume a public-sidewalk fall is hopeless, but do move quickly.

The Filing Deadline for Private Property

For falls on private commercial or residential property, Michigan's statute of limitations is generally three years from the date of the fall. That sounds like plenty of time, but the evidence that wins these cases — weather records, plowing logs, surveillance video — disappears within days or weeks. Early action preserves it.

What to Do After an Icy Fall — A Checklist

1. Get medical attention promptly. Adrenaline masks fractures and head injuries; get checked even if you feel "just sore."
2. Photograph the ice immediately — before anyone salts or plows it. Capture the exact patch, its size, and the surrounding area.
3. Photograph the source if you can — a downspout, a plow ridge, a slope where water pools and refreezes.
4. Report the fall to the business or landlord and get an incident report and copy.
5. Note the date, time, and temperature — weather data can prove how long the ice had been there.
6. Get witness names and numbers.
7. Keep the shoes and clothing you wore to counter "bad footwear" arguments.
8. Don't give a recorded statement to the insurer or accept a fast, lowball offer before talking to a lawyer.

Bottom Line

Ice is a fact of Michigan life, but that doesn't give a business or landlord a free pass to ignore it. Thanks to recent changes in Michigan law, injured people have a far stronger hand than they used to — if the fall is documented and the case is built quickly. If a winter fall put you in a cast or on the surgery schedule, it's worth finding out what your claim is really worth.

« Back to all blog posts